Best Places for Used Bikes in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Looking for a great deal on a bike in Milwaukee? Whether you’re upgrading your ride or hunting for an affordable entry-level option, Milwaukee has several fantastic spots to buy and sell used bicycles. From nonprofit shops to full-service bike stores, there’s something for every rider and budget. Here’s a breakdown of the best bricks and mortar places in Milwaukee to explore used bike options.

Physical Locations (Bricks and Mortar Shops)

Wheel & Sprocket – Bay View📍

📍 Address: 187 E Becher St Suite A, Milwaukee, WI 53207
🌐 Website: wheelandsprocket.com
⭐ Rating: 4.6 (81 reviews)

Wheel & Sprocket is one of Milwaukee’s best-known bike shops, and their Bay View location offers an impressive selection of used bikes for all types—road, mountain, hybrid, and even kids’ bikes. They also accept trade-ins and use Bicycle Blue Book values to ensure a fair deal when selling your bike. It’s a trusted stop whether you’re buying or selling.

DreamBikes Milwaukee📍

📍 Address: 2021 N Dr Martin Luther King Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53212
🌐 Website: dream-bikes.org
⭐ Rating: 3.5 (10 reviews)

DreamBikes is more than a bike shop—it’s a nonprofit organization making a real impact in the community. They refurbish donated bicycles and resell them at affordable prices, while also providing job training for local youth. You can donate or purchase bikes here, and occasionally they accept bikes for resale. It’s a meaningful way to buy or sell with purpose.

Vulture Space📍

Address: 651 N Plankinton Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53203
🌐 Website: vulturespace.org

Vulture Space is a nonprofit community bike shop and do-it-yourself repair hub. While they’re more known for their community programs and repair workspace, they also sell refurbished bikes at budget-friendly prices. If you’re mechanically inclined, you can even use their shop tools to fix up your own bike before selling or donating it.

Ben’s Cycle📍

Address: 1016 Lincoln Ave (9th), Milwaukee, WI 53215
🌐 Website: benscycle.com
⭐ Rating: 3.2 (20 reviews)

A Milwaukee cycling institution since 1928, Ben’s Cycle offers everything from basic rides to high-performance machines. Their inventory includes new and used bikes, and they also deal in parts, accessories, and custom builds through their Milwaukee Bicycle Co. brand. If you have a quality bike to sell, Ben’s is worth checking out for a fair price and expert advice.

Whether you’re trying to sell a bike gathering dust in your garage or looking for a great deal on a used ride, Milwaukee has no shortage of trusted bike shops and community-focused programs. Wheel & Sprocket offers trade-in value and variety, DreamBikes and Vulture Space support local causes, and Ben’s Cycle provides expertise and legacy service.

Before heading out, be sure to check each shop’s current hours and inventory online. And if you’re selling, giving your bike a quick tune-up could go a long way in securing a better deal!

Online Market Places For Used Bicycles

Facebook Marketplace

🌐 Website: facebook.com/marketplace

Why it’s great for Milwaukee:
Facebook Marketplace is one of the most active local marketplaces in Milwaukee. Users can quickly search for bikes in their area, filter by price or type, and message sellers directly. It’s especially popular for quick, local pickups and price negotiation.

Tips:

• Check seller profiles for credibility
• Meet in public places for safety
• Be ready to act fast—good bikes go quickly

Craigslist Milwaukee

🌐 Website: milwaukee.craigslist.org

Why it’s still relevant:
Craigslist remains a go-to platform for used bike transactions in Milwaukee. The “Bicycles” category is filled with listings ranging from cheap commuter bikes to high-end road and mountain bikes.

Tips:

• Listings are unverified, so be cautious
• Always test ride before buying
• Scams can occur—trust your instincts

OfferUp (formerly Letgo)

🌐 Website: offerup.com

Why locals like it:
OfferUp is a mobile-friendly app and website popular for casual, peer-to-peer buying. It’s location-based, so you can browse listings specifically around the Milwaukee area. Ratings and reviews help you evaluate seller reputation.

Tips:

• Use in-app messaging to communicate safely
• Compare prices with similar listings
• Verify bike condition in person

9 Bears Marketplace

🌐 Website: 9 Bears

New guy on the block:
An up an coming cycling hub, 9 Bears has a free buy sell marketplace for cycling (and ski for you winter sport enthusiasts). Easy and free you may as well take advantage of it.

Tips:

• Ideal for casual and family-oriented bike sales
• Ski and snowboard section
• Easy signup process

The Pro’s Closet (for high-end used bikes)

🌐 Website: theproscloset.com

Why it stands out:
While not Milwaukee-specific, The Pro’s Closet is a trusted platform for buying and selling high-end used bicycles nationwide. Sellers ship bikes in, and buyers get a certified pre-owned bike with inspection and warranty.

Tips:

• More expensive, but professionally vetted
• Ideal for serious riders and racers
• Great resale option for high-value bikes

Honorable Mentions:

• eBay – Still used for niche or rare bikes
• Local Reddit threads (r/milwaukee, r/cycling) – Occasionally have buy/sell posts

5 practical tips for selling your used bicycle

Clean and tune it up first. A well-maintained bike sells faster and for more money. Clean the frame, degrease the chain, inflate the tires, and make basic adjustments. If brakes or gears need work, consider a quick tune-up at a bike shop – the investment often pays for itself in a higher sale price.

Price it realistically. Research similar bikes on Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, or cycling forums to understand market value. Factor in the bike’s age, condition, brand, and original retail price. Most used bikes sell for 40-60% of their original price, depending on condition and demand.

Take quality photos in good lighting. Shoot the bike from multiple angles – full side view, close-ups of components, and any wear or damage. Natural outdoor lighting works best. Include photos of the drivetrain, brakes, and any upgraded parts that add value.

Write a detailed, honest description. Include the brand, model, size, year if known, and any upgrades or recent maintenance. Be upfront about any issues or wear – this builds trust and prevents wasted time with buyers who show up expecting something different.

Meet in a safe, public location. Arrange test rides in well-lit public areas like parking lots or bike paths. Bring a friend if possible, and let the buyer know they can inspect the bike thoroughly. Having basic bike knowledge ready helps answer questions and shows you’ve cared for the bike properly. Make sure to get some form of official picture ID and something of value before they hop on it for test ride!