Used Bikes in Hamilton, Ontario: Where to Buy & Sell Safely

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Buy Used Bikes In Person in Hamilton

New Hope Community Bikes

Address: 1249 Main St. E, Hamilton, ON
Affordable refurbished bikes—often under $300—and parts with a community-driven mission.
New Hope Community Bikes

Downtown Bike Hounds

Address: 19 John Street North, Hamilton, ON
A local favorite for quality used bikes, accessories & repairs; open daily 10 am–6 pm (Spring/Summer hours).
Bike Hounds

Other Local Options

Look into “Eddies Used Bikes” and other listings featured in local business directories.

Sell Your Used Bike in Person in and around Hamilton

Some local shops offer trade-in or purchase options (expect lower resale value).
For safer private sales, Hamilton Police Safe Exchange Zones are highly recommended.

Local Bike Shops (Trade-In or Cash Offers)

Some shops may buy used bikes—though expect less than private‑sale value. Trade‑in programs often offer a mix of credit and convenience, but prices reflect resale risk.

New Hope Community Bikes

• Address: 1249 Main St. E, Hamilton, ON
• A community-focused charity that refurbishes donated bikes and sells them. While not a traditional resale shop, they accept used bike donations, which is an easy and meaningful way to move on your bike. New Hope Community Bikes

Downtown Bike Hounds

• Address: 19 John Street North, Hamilton, ON
• Known for offering a variety of bikes and repairs. While their focus is on retail and service, it’s worth asking whether they accept used bikes on consignment or trade-in, especially if your bike is in good condition. Bike Hounds

Rolling Horse

• A non-profit bicycle shop that offers refurbished bike sales and participates in community programs. They may be open to taking in good-condition used bikes for resale or reuse.
  Rolling Horse

Eddies Used Bikes & Other Local Shops

• Featured on local review platforms like Yelp as used-bike spots. While details may vary, these shops are worth contacting to see if they buy or accept used bikes directly.
  Eddies Used Bikes

Safe Public Swap Zones (Hamilton Police)

Many police stations in Hamilton offer designated “Safe Buy & Sell” exchange zones—public, monitored, and ideal for greater safety.

Reddit advice emphasizes:

“Do the exchange at a police station…”
“Only allow them to test‑ride the bike if they hand you the cash to hold while they ride it.” Reddit

Online Marketplaces for Hamilton Buyers & Sellers

• 9 Bears – Up and coming online marketplace dedicated to cycling and ski
• Karrot – Hamilton-specific listings for bikes at various price points.
• Facebook Marketplace – Widely used platform for local bike sales.
• Kijiji – Great for frames, parts, or complete bikes with local reach.
• BicycleBlueBook.com – Offers valuation tools and secure listing options for broader exposure.

Buying & Selling Tips (Safety First!)

• Meet in public, trusted places – police stations have Safe Exchange Zones.
• Secure payment first – require cash or confirmed e-transfer before handing over the bike.
• Verify users – longer-standing accounts and normal profiles = more trustworthy.
• Watch for stolen bikes – ask for ownership proof and watch serial numbers.
• Price realistically – use online tools like BicycleBlueBook; expect ~50% of retail.
• Prepare clear listings – good photos, honest descriptions, and testing expectations clearly stated.